What a retail or loss-prevention manager needs to know about the shopkeeper's privilege before stopping anyone.
Kentucky's merchant's privilege statute is more detailed than most, spelling out exactly why and how a suspect can be held — which is helpful, but it also means there are more specific ways to get it wrong. Managers who detain someone for a reason the statute doesn't list are operating without its protection.
KRS 433.236 lets a merchant, employee, security agent, or peace officer with probable cause take a suspected shoplifter into custody and detain them in a reasonable manner for a reasonable time, on the premises or off premises if in fresh pursuit. The statute specifically lists acceptable purposes: verifying identity, recovering goods, and notifying or surrendering the person to police. Reasonable force is allowed to prevent escape or loss of goods, but deadly force is never justified to protect merchandise — that line is explicit in the statute, not implied.
The most common misstep is detaining someone for a purpose the statute doesn't cover — lecturing them, trying to extract a confession, or holding them to make an example in front of other customers rather than to verify identity or recover goods. The second is force: because KRS 433.236 permits reasonable force but explicitly bars deadly force over property, any physical escalation beyond what's needed to prevent someone from walking away is a serious liability exposure, not a gray area.
Kentucky's statute names "security agent" alongside merchant and employee, which signals that trained security personnel are the intended frontline for these stops. Because Kentucky lacks one uniform statewide licensing regime, retailers should confirm with counsel or the Kentucky Department of Criminal Justice Training exactly what training and credentialing apply to any contracted security staff — that documentation is what shows a court the detention was handled by someone who understood the statute's purpose and force limits, not an untrained employee improvising under pressure.
Yes, KRS 433.236 allows detention off the premises if the merchant or employee is in fresh pursuit — meaning they followed the person immediately, not that they tracked them down later.
Reasonable force to prevent escape or protect property is allowed, but the statute is explicit that deadly force is never justified solely to protect goods. Staff should treat any physical contact beyond blocking an exit as a serious escalation.
Tell us about your store or portfolio and we’ll help you staff it correctly.
Request a Consultation